Delicious Club Sandwich Layers

This classic Club Sandwich recipe transforms ordinary ingredients into an impressive triple-decker masterpiece that’s perfect for lunch or a light dinner. The combination of savory turkey, crispy bacon, and fresh vegetables creates layers of flavor and texture that make this sandwich a timeless favorite.

I first made this club sandwich for my husband after we returned from a trip to New York where he fell in love with the hotel room service version. My homemade version quickly became his weekend lunch request, and now I keep the ingredients on hand for impromptu gatherings.

Ingredients

• Sandwich bread: The foundation of your club sandwich, look for a quality white bread that toasts well without being too thick
• Turkey breast: Provides lean protein, choose freshly sliced deli turkey rather than prepackaged for better flavor and texture
• White American cheese: Adds creaminess and mild flavor that complements the other ingredients without overpowering
• Turkey bacon: Gives that essential savory crunch while being lighter than traditional bacon
• Fresh tomato: Adds juiciness and acidity, choose ripe but firm tomatoes and slice them medium-thick
• Shredded lettuce: Provides crisp texture and freshness, iceberg or romaine work beautifully here
• Mayo or spicy mayo: The binding ingredient that adds richness, make your own spicy version by mixing in sriracha or hot sauce

Step-by-Step Instructions

Toast the Bread:

Begin by toasting all six bread slices until they're golden brown and have a slight crunch. This critical step prevents your sandwich from becoming soggy once assembled.

Prepare the Vegetables:

Slice your tomato into medium-thick rounds, about ¼ inch each. Shred your lettuce into thin strips for easy layering. Having these ready streamlines the assembly process.

Spread the Foundation:

Arrange three bread slices on your work surface and generously spread mayo on one side of all six slices. This ensures flavor in every layer of your sandwich.

Build the First Layer:

On your first slice of bread, layer the turkey breast, tomato slices, and American cheese. The order matters as the cheese helps hold ingredients in place when melting slightly against the warm toast.

Add the Middle Slice:

Place the second bread slice on top with the mayo side facing down, then spread mayo on the top side of this middle slice. This middle piece is crucial for the classic club structure.

Complete the Stack:

Add your turkey bacon and shredded lettuce on top of the middle slice, then crown with the final bread slice, mayo side down. The proper layering creates the perfect bite with all flavors represented.

Secure and Slice:

Insert sandwich picks through all layers to hold everything together, then use a sharp knife to cut the sandwich into four triangular or rectangular sections. Clean cuts make for an impressive presentation.

Pin it

The first time I served these sandwiches at a family gathering, my brother-in-law who claims to hate tomatoes devoured two portions without complaint. The secret was using perfectly ripe summer tomatoes that added juiciness without the mealy texture that turns many people away.

Make-Ahead Tips

You can prepare all the components up to a day in advance and store them separately in airtight containers in the refrigerator. The bread should be toasted just before assembly to maintain its texture. If you need to make the sandwiches a few hours ahead, wrap them tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate, but be aware that the bread may soften slightly over time.

Serving Suggestions

The club sandwich stands confidently on its own, but traditional accompaniments include crispy potato chips, French fries, or a simple side salad. For a more substantial meal, add a cup of tomato soup or a light coleslaw. When serving for a gathering, consider cutting into smaller sections and securing with decorative picks for an elegant presentation that’s easy to handle.

Creative Variations

While the traditional club sandwich follows a specific formula, there’s room for delicious customization. Try using sourdough or whole grain bread for additional flavor. Substitute rotisserie chicken for turkey, or add avocado slices for creaminess. Vegetarians can enjoy a version with grilled portobello mushrooms instead of meat. For a breakfast-inspired variation, include a fried egg between the layers.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What is the best bread for this club sandwich?

Toasted sandwich bread works best for its sturdy texture and slight crispness, holding the layers well.

→ Can I substitute the turkey?

Yes, you can use chicken, ham, or even a vegetarian option like roasted vegetables or tofu.

→ How do I keep the sandwich from falling apart?

Secure each sandwich with sturdy picks or skewers before slicing into smaller pieces.

→ Is spicy mayo necessary?

No, regular mayo works perfectly, but spicy mayo adds a flavorful kick if preferred.

→ Can I prepare this in advance?

It's best enjoyed fresh, but you can toast the bread, cook the bacon, and prep the ingredients ahead of time for quick assembly.